?

Leaning right, leaning left, YBH!
Wednesday February 1st 2012

American Soccer Player Refuses to Put Hand on Heart During National Anthem

Share in an emailShare on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Stumble UponShare on RedditShare on DiggSubscribe to Yes, But, However!Print this articleybh spacer

NEW YORK (YBH) – During the national anthem at the beginning of U.S. soccer matches this year one player will be standing apart from his teammates.  American forward Jozy Altidore stands with his hands down during the national anthem.  The rest of the U.S. national team keeps their hand on their heart in the traditional manner for sports teams representing the country.

Mr. Altidore’s parents came to the United States from Haiti 35 years ago.  Speculation is ripe that Mr. Altidore’s weaker on field performances are due to the fact that his parents homeland was devastated by a terrible earthquake earlier this year.  What isn’t clear is why Mr. Altidore chooses to ignore the national anthem.  Mr. Altidore, a 20 year-old American striker, has spent his entire life living in the United States.

Mr. Altidore believes that his World Cup performance will help bring to light the plight of the people of Haiti saying, “My only message would be just to imagine how you would feel if it was your son or daughter that is … 5, 6, 7 years old and they’re living on the street. It’s tough for me to think about every day, which is why I’m happy I can have this opportunity and try to represent not only myself, but them as well.”

While advocating Haitian relief is quite honorable, it doesn’t answer why Mr. Altidore refuses to honor the American flag during the national anthem.  Perhaps in 2014 he would prefer to play for Haiti’s national team?  It is not out of the question as Mr. Altidore has admittedly been torn between his U.S. citizenship, even though he has spent his entire life here, and his Haitian heritage.  We hope not, as Mr. Altidore is a talented player even with a less than stellar year of soccer under his belt.

Dual citizenship, or heritage, is only a real problem when someone is torn between the two.  There is nothing irreconcilable between honoring the American national anthem and helping those in Haiti.  Let’s hope Mr. Altidore understands that.  We need his mind on scoring goals not making political statements.

Related posts:

  1. Frontiers of Marketing: Mercedes Gives British Teen a Hand: A Branded Prosthetic One
  2. Jim Thome 600th Home Run: Minnesota Twins Slugger Becomes Eighth Player To Reach Milestone (VIDEO)
  3. SportsWatch: Fox pushes English soccer alongside NFL
John Romano is the publisher and editor of Yes, But However!, a musician, a former political correspondent for BBC Radio London, and a serial web entrepreneur. Follow him on twitter: twitter.com/yesbuthowever or John Romano on Google+

article archive.

Post Published: 18 June 2010
Found in section: News and Analysis, Sports and Entertainment
  • http://intensedebate.com/people/EPorvaznik EPorvaznik

    >>Mr. Altidore believes that his World Cup performance will help bring to light the plight of the people of Haiti>>

    Jozy, that's only going to happen if you score goals (or dish some assists). Little somethin'-somethin' to consider in Wednesday's big "win and you're in" chance for the US to advance further on the world stage. Hand, heart, shut up and play.

  • yvrose

    President Obama once did the same thing and forgot to put his hand over his heart during the playing of the national anthem. That did not stop him from being elected, nor from becoming an effectice president.
    True leaders never just shut up and play….

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/EPorvaznik EPorvaznik

      You'll be sure to let YBH know when President Obama starts to become effective, right?

  • USSoccerFan

    He should put his hand over his heart if he wants to play for the US National team. If not, go play for Haiti!

  • OutWithAltidore

    Altidore is free to express himself in any way he chooses. However, his choice is not without consequences. If he is not proud to represent the US, then he should not represent the US. I believe he would be a standout player for the Haitian national team. Perhaps he would even perform better than he did for the US.

    He should also recognize that, while the remaining players chose–regardless of their personal convictions–to be unified during the national anthem, his failure to render respect not only reflected poorly on himself as an American, but also on his ability to be a conscientious and effective teammate. Check your personal convictions at the door. Enjoy your time at the 2014 World Cup with Haiti.

    Oh, BTW, the US didn't cause the earthquake. But we sure did commit quite a bit of money and manpower to making things better in Haiti. How about just saying thank you and being happy for what has been done so far?

  • The hand on the chest is for pledges, not the national anthem

    The hand is supposed to go on the heart during pledges and oaths, not during the national anthem. Go back to footage even twenty years ago, and you’ll see President Reagan with his hands at his sides during the national anthem.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Bville-Doc/100000215663799 Bville Doc

    Probably making something out of nothing. But, for the record, since Mr. Altidore has already played multiple international matches for the US, by FIFA rules, he is no longer eligible to play internationally for anyone else, Haiti or otherwise.