?

Leaning right, leaning left, YBH!
Wednesday February 1st 2012

Joe Wilson Admonished by House Over Outburst

Share in an emailShare on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Stumble UponShare on RedditShare on DiggSubscribe to Yes, But, However!Print this articleybh spacer

WASHINGTON, D.C. (YBH.ME) – The House of Representatives has voted largely along party lines to admonish Rep. Joe Wilson for calling President Obama a liar during the President’s speech to a Joint Session of Congress last week.  The vote is the first of it’s kind.

South Carolina Rep. Joe Wilson admonished by House.

South Carolina Rep. Joe Wilson admonished by House.

Mr. Wilson, frustrated over what he believes were misstatements by the President over whether illegal immigrants would be included in any health care reform package, yelled “You Lie!” during the President’s speech.  Mr. Wilson quickly apologized to the President.  President Obama accepted Mr. Wilson’s overture.

The final vote was 240-179 in favor of the admonishment.

Related posts:

  1. Budget Deal Passes House Vote
  2. Flashback: 37 House Dems Voted Against Raising Debt Ceiling in 2010
  3. Boehner Bill Passes House: A View From the Speaker’s Office
  4. White House Dossier: Warren and Barack’s Gift to America
John Romano is the publisher and editor of Yes, But However!, a musician, a former political correspondent for BBC Radio London, and a serial web entrepreneur. Follow him on twitter: twitter.com/yesbuthowever or John Romano on Google+

article archive.

Post Published: 15 September 2009
Found in section: News and Analysis, Politics
  • http://intensedebate.com/people/snookman007 snookman007

    The Man called it like he saw it. Good for him. Guts man Guts

  • http://miserablegrouch.blogspot.com/ gaiuscaprica

    There is something seemingly comforting on Joe Wilson’s outburst to the president. It reminds us that it is our right as Americans to stand up to our government including the president. However I find it unsettling that Wilson never showed this kind of fortitude during the Bush era. Lets face; it there is a lot of misunderstanding regarding the presidents healthcare plan but lies? Ponder on these lies- Iraq has weapons of mass destruction, we are wining the war on terrorism, we (USA) do not torture prisoners, – why no passionate outburst from Wilson then? Now all of a sudden Wilson and republicans are touting patriotic ideals? What about Katrina, or Abu Ghraib? Not to mention the lack of cojones when we faced the gas, home foreclosure and economic crisis, no fingers were pointed, no one called (Bush) names by Wilson and his brethrens. I guess is all Obama’s fault. he forgot that for nearly a decade we got used to a blubbering idiot and not someone with a mastering of standard American English-“for a black man” as was often repeated by all during elections.
    It is often easier to fight for principles than to live up to them. – Adlai Stevenson

  • JaToya

    Please. Whatever your opinion, that was the wrong time to do it. In fact, I think it gave Obama a boost, for which I am heartily grateful.

    This politician showed a decided lack of judgement, and as a representative of his people an admonishment is the least of what should have been done. Alas, we live in the US of A and though I would have it no other way, freedom of speech prevails and gives impromptu platforms to those who apparently haven't a clue how to access the right channels to make their opinions known.

    This man was thoughtless, kind of like Kanye West at the VMAs, except Kanye at least had the excuse of being drunk. Unfortunately there isn't much we can do about Wilson's actions, except a public admonishment.

    How sad.

  • Greg

    Actually, this was exactly the time and place to do it. If you ever watch CSpan, there is never more than a fraction of the house present for any debate. A great speech, on any political issue, maybe heard by 50 members of Congress. Even more importantly, only a few hundred or thousand Americans would hear it live.

    When Mr. Wilson made his statement it was on national tv, seen by millions, and affirmed by millions. With those two words his voice and the voice of many many Americans was heard. It was impulsive and it was out of line. He will be punished, in some way, shape, or form. However, he did get in point across and you can't un-ring that bell. More importantly he acted as the voice for so many that have not voice.

    Both sides need to realize that this all or nothing bull isn't going to work. Common sense says, push through what both side agree upon, then debate the other issues. The problem here is that so many people don't agree with this agenda which is what they feel is being shoved down their throats. What makes it worst is that the number aren't 80-20 or even 60-40 like the election, its much closer than that. We truly are a nation divided on this and all other issues.

    People react when they are pushed. Thats exactly what Rep. Wilson did, and he pushed back!

  • Dan

    Thank you Joe Wilson!! You were the mouthpiece for the silenced Americans! You showed us that we can still speak the truth in the halls of congress! You spoke and the babies cried!

    I think Americans are tired of eloquent speaches full of fountains of promises that can/will never be fulfilled. He speaks to itching ears, and then goes behind closed doors and does what he wants.

  • Justice

    Its the Republican way. Its always the correct thing to do or say if its done by a Republican. However, if the same action, comment, bill, or (just fill in the blank) is done by the opposition, Republicans scream bloody hell. Fear, mob mentality, prejudices, and greed are the driving forces of the GOP. Helping others is now commonly known to Republicans as being Socialist. Finding common ground is impossible unless it is the Replubicans idea. America wanted change, now Republicans only fear change. Conservatives true meaning at its core, do not change, "help myself", do not help America as a whole to move forward. 'Divided we stand or else', its the Republican way.

  • Smilesrfree

    The House has rules and part of the rules specifically state that you a member of the House, a lawmaker can say a president’s policies are a “disgrace to the country,” but they are not allowed to call the president a “hypocrite” or a “liar.” When you become a member of the House you agree to follow the House rules. If you as a House member feel that these rules are outdated, then they should work for change. But the rules are there for a reason.

  • Pete

    Party lines are party lines. The whole lot in Washington is a joke. Look at the vote to admonish. The only ones I have respect for are the few Democrates that voted no and the few Republicans that votes yes. Wilson needed to say what he said, was it important – yes, was it badly times – yes, did it help his campaign drive – yes, should he take his medicine – yes.

  • Ben

    Its not the 'Republican' way. Its the American political way. The Democrats whined while Bush was in office, now the Republicans are whining with the Democrats in power. This also happened during the Clinton years, and I imagine the Reagan years as well (although I was too young to care in those days). Our two major political parties are a joke and a disgrace. I am a conservative, but no longer identify with the Republicans. If I was liberal, I think I would feel the same about the Democrats.

    That sad, I can admire the guts of Wilson to do that, but he still has to take the heat. He is a politician, and if he didn't expect a backlash then he really is an idiot.

  • Greg

    Keep up the fight Joe. Obama is a liar. The health care plan WILL cover illegal aliens. LIE. Plain and simple and Joe called Obama out. Obama is a damn liar.

    • http://miserablegrouch.blogspot.com/ gaiuscaprica

      Greg educate yourself you may lack the attention span to read all the 1018 pages but this will show that
      WILSON LIED, not Obama.
      HR 3200 Page 143 Sec 246:

      SEC. 246. NO FEDERAL PAYMENT FOR UNDOCUMENTED ALIENS.
      Nothing in this subtitle shall allow Federal payments for affordability credits on behalf of individuals who are not lawfully present in the United States.
      http://edlabor.house.gov/documents/111/pdf/public…

  • paula

    Joe Wilson is an embarrassment. Interesting that his taxpayer paid for website was down for several days and now all that is there is his biography…no way to send a comment. I don't think this is democracy in action. Regardless of the party affiliation, it is critical to our national security to not have such scenes as the Joe Wilson inappropriate shout out play on the international stage. The fact that Joe Wilson has no control of his emotions should be of concern to his constituents. Not to mention, he was wrong. There is no accommodation in the bill for illegals to be covered. I question how many of either party have read the proposals. Politicians seem to care about being reelected. They don't seem to have much concern for the rest of us.

  • Tire of it all

    Democrats are Hypocrites. They've pushed me into the other camp and awakened my anger. I've watched Democrats on the house floor call Bush a liar. I've heard Pelosi call the CIA liars. I've heard about the Chairman of the Ways and Means committee cheat over and over on his taxes…democrat. Nothing is done until now?
    Split the nation in two. That's what they've done. This is going to get worse. AND, if I hear the 'racist' remark one more time, I think I'll barf. The only people that focus on the president being black, are blacks. Take off the colored glasses and get over yourselves. It's about policies NOT RACE!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/gailjoshua gailjoshua

    Gaiuscaprica – I too find it unsettling that Joe Wilson’s disrespectful outburst to the President was over illegal immigrants' healthcare. Why DIDN'T he show this kind of opposition when Bush said “Iraq has weapons of mass destruction”, or “we are wining the war on terrorism,” or “the USA does not torture prisoners?” Shouldn’t he have passionately objected to SOMETHING regarding Hurricane Katrina, or high gas prices, or home foreclosures or economic bailouts? Yet, no one disrespected Bush. Thank God our President gracefully accepted Wilson’s apology. If it were me, I’d have Wilson tortured at Abu Ghraib. At least Kanye had the excuse of being drunk, and had the decency to apologize every chance he got!

    • http://miserablegrouch.blogspot.com/ gaiuscaprica

      Well said gailijoshua…

      I have respect for KW because he has apologized not only to Taylor Swift( which he had to) but to all including the viewers (which he didn't have to) Wilson as an elected official represents us all. the worst insult he can give is refusing to apologize to us the people as well. When he stands on the congress he is to embody our will, not his own agenda.